When two observables commute — their commutator is zero — they can share a complete set of eigenstates. In a shared eigenstate both observables hold definite, sharp values at the same time. When the commutator is nonzero, as it is for position and momentum, no such shared eigenstate exists, so the two quantities can never both be sharp at once. That is the structural reason the classical picture of definite values breaks down.
Non-Commuting Observables: Why Quantum Mechanics Is More Fundamental
Why Order Matters: Commutators and the Classical Assumption
When Commutators Vanish
5 / 5
When the commutator is zero, the two observables can share eigenstates. In a shared eigenstate both have definite values at once.
0:00 / 0:00