Non-commutativity is never switched off; it is outscaled. The comparison that matters is between ℏ, about 1.05 × 10⁻³⁴ joule-seconds, and the action of the system, which carries the same units. For a thrown ball the action is on the order of a joule-second, so the ratio of ℏ to the action comes out around 10⁻³⁴. The commutator [x, p] = iℏ is still exactly nonzero, but its effect on any measurable quantity sits below what any instrument could resolve. So classical behavior is not the absence of quantum rules; it is the regime where those rules are numerically invisible.
Non-Commuting Observables: Why Quantum Mechanics Is More Fundamental
The Classical Limit: Why Everyday Physics Emerges from Quantum Mechanics
When the Commutator Stops Mattering
1 / 5
Last time we saw that a sharp position measurement leaves momentum broad, and that no joint distribution over position and momentum can match what quantum mechanics predicts. So how does a thrown ball still land where Newton says it will?
0:00 / 0:00