For position x and momentum p the commutator is not zero. It takes the fixed value [x, p] = iℏ, where ℏ is the reduced Planck constant. The factor i is the imaginary unit, and it is not a bookkeeping trick: it tells you the relation cannot be written with ordinary real numbers at all. Position and momentum are operators whose order of multiplication genuinely changes the result, and the size of that change is fixed by ℏ. No classical assignment of definite values can imitate this structure.
Non-Commuting Observables: Why Quantum Mechanics Is More Fundamental
Why Order Matters: Commutators and the Classical Assumption
The Canonical Relation
4 / 5
For position and momentum the commutator is not zero. It equals i times h-bar, the reduced Planck constant.
0:00 / 0:00