Argon-argon dating assumes that all the argon-40 in a mineral was produced by potassium-40 decay after the mineral cooled, and that none of it escaped afterwards. When a mineral traps argon from the surrounding magma at formation, the measured age comes out older than the true age. When a later heating event lets argon diffuse out, the measured age comes out younger. In both cases the analytical measurement can still be highly repeatable, so the quoted uncertainty stays narrow while the age itself is displaced. That is why a precise argon-argon age is not automatically an accurate one.
How Argon-Argon Dating Accuracy and Precision Shape Causal Claims in the Geologic Record
Where the Clock Fails: Limits, Biases, and Cross-Method Comparison
Precise but Wrong
1 / 3
The whole Cretaceous-Paleogene argument rested on argon-argon ages being trustworthy. So take a single mineral grain and ask what could go wrong inside it. The clock assumes every argon-40 atom in that grain came from potassium-40 decay after the grain cooled, and that none of them left afterwards.
0:00 / 0:00