Improved precision narrowed the uncertainty bands on the Cretaceous-Paleogene events. With wide bands, a single-cause impact scenario and a combined impact-and-volcanism scenario both stay consistent with the dates. With tighter bands, the combined scenario becomes better supported, because the impact and the intensified volcanism fall close enough together to have acted as a sequence rather than as unrelated events.
How Argon-Argon Dating Accuracy and Precision Shape Causal Claims in the Geologic Record
From Temporal Order to Causal Claims: The Cretaceous-Paleogene Test Case
When the Bars Narrow
3 / 3
Now narrow those bars. As precision improves, the spacing between the impact and the volcanic eruptions becomes resolvable, and the two scenarios stop looking equally good.
0:00 / 0:00