Put the pieces together and the relation between the two theories becomes clear. Start with the non-commutative algebra, let ℏ become negligible compared with the action, and the operators turn into ordinary commuting numbers; the equations become Newton's. The reverse does not work. Classical mechanics has no ℏ to tune, no commutator to switch on, and no mechanism to generate superposition or interference. You cannot recover the uncertainty relation or back-action from a theory whose quantities all commute. The reduction runs one way, which is what it means to say quantum mechanics is the more fundamental theory.
Non-Commuting Observables: Why Quantum Mechanics Is More Fundamental
The Classical Limit: Why Everyday Physics Emerges from Quantum Mechanics
One Direction Only
4 / 5
We now have three ingredients: the commutator becomes negligible, expectation values follow Newton, and decoherence erases interference. Put them together and the relationship between the theories comes into focus.
0:00 / 0:00