Classical physics assumes every particle has a definite position and a definite momentum at every instant, so in principle you could sort many particles into a two-dimensional histogram over (x, p) and read off both marginals by summing along rows and columns. For non-commuting observables this fails. The position marginal and the momentum marginal that quantum mechanics predicts cannot both be marginals of one joint distribution, because the joint distribution would have to assign probabilities to pairs of values that no state can realize simultaneously.
Non-Commuting Observables: Why Quantum Mechanics Is More Fundamental
Measurement, Disturbance, and the Breakdown of Classical Description
Why No Joint Histogram Exists
3 / 5
Back-action already tells us that measuring one observable disturbs the other. But there is a stronger claim hiding here. In classical physics, every particle has a definite position and a definite momentum at every moment, whether or not anyone looks. If that were true, you could sort many particles into a two-dimensional histogram over position and momentum and read both distributions off its edges.
0:00 / 0:00