Testing a chain like this needs an eruption whose date is already known from something other than radiometric dating. The 79 CE eruption of Vesuvius buried Pompeii, and Pliny the Younger's account fixes the date independently of any measurement in the laboratory. Eight sanidine samples from that eruption were dated with the recalibrated argon-argon system at 1,938 ± 13 years before analysis in 2025, against a historical age of 1,946 years. That corresponds to about 0.7 percent precision and 0.4 percent accuracy. The same work revised the potassium-40 to argon-40 half-life to 12.044 ± 0.088 billion years, roughly twice as precise as the previous nuclear-physics value, which tightens accuracy for every argon-argon age rather than only for Vesuvius.
How Argon-Argon Dating Accuracy and Precision Shape Causal Claims in the Geologic Record
Standards, Fluence Monitors, and the Calibration Chain
Testing the Chain on a Dated Eruption
3 / 3
So how do you test a chain like that? You need an eruption whose date is already known from something other than radiometric dating.
0:00 / 0:00