When dominance cycles, the useful question changes from 'which option is best' to 'which option is best against this opponent'. A decision tree makes the shift visible: the same set of options branches differently depending on which alternative each one is compared with, and the branch labeled best moves as the opponent changes. This pattern is not limited to dice. In majority voting, three candidates can each beat one rival and lose to another even when every voter's own ranking is perfectly consistent, a situation known as a Condorcet cycle. The same structure appears whenever a choice is made by pairwise comparison rather than by a single global score.
Non-Transitive Dice: The Endless Dominance Spiral
What the Spiral Means for Probability and Choice
Best Against What
4 / 5
If no die is best overall, the question has to change. Instead of asking which option is best, ask which option is best against the one you are actually facing.
0:00 / 0:00