Efron's three dice form a cycle, but that cycle can still take on new members. A fourth die D can be built so that it beats one existing die and loses to another, which keeps the whole set a single directed cycle. The requirement is that D must both win an edge and lose an edge. A die that only won would turn the loop into a chain with a top, and a die that only lost would create a bottom.
Non-Transitive Dice: The Endless Dominance Spiral
Why the Spiral Never Ends
A Fourth Die Joins the Loop
1 / 5
Efron's three dice already close a loop, so the arrows run A to B, B to C, and C back to A. Nothing in that set is strongest. But a closed loop can still take on new members — a fourth die can be built and pushed inside it.
0:00 / 0:00